The Fear That’s Hurting You More Than Osteoporosis
How a generation of women was told to stop moving — and why that advice was never based on evidence
“I’m not allowed to do that pose, because I have osteopenia,” Susanne said. “I even had to stop riding my bike, because I’m not allowed to do any twisting or rotation, so I can’t turn my head to watch for traffic.”
From the sound of it, you may assume that Susanne was a frail, 80-year-old woman with poor posture and poor balance, in which case this would all make a lot of sense
But she was not. She was a healthy, fit, vital 50-something with no physical complaints. By all accounts, she was on a trajectory to enjoy another two to three decades of full mobility and health.
But that all changed dramatically when she received a routine DEXA-scan diagnosis of osteopenia.
From one day to the next, Susanne’s self-image was completely transformed. She shifted from being an independent, healthy menopausal woman to feeling vulnerable and frail. She felt like her body was slowly betraying her, and began to live in constant fear of fractures. And as a result, she began to move less and less.
This happened in one of our yoga classes about fifteen years ago. But it was not an isolated instance. In teaching yoga over the past two decades, we have met far too many women like Susanne. If you are a yoga teacher, chances are that you have as well. Or, you may yourself have been diagnosed with osteoporosis or osteopenia and are well familiar with the fear of fractures that diagnosis brings with it.
For people with osteoporosis, we are told, any wrong movement — particularly forward bending or twisting — could result in a fracture. Don’t get me wrong: osteoporosis is not a condition to be taken lightly. But far too many women are unable to evaluate the real significance of their DEXA-scan score, and end up curtailing their activity and moving less and less.
That creates the exact opposite result of what they are trying to avoid. Reducing physical activity puts you at higher risk of fractures — and a host of other health conditions to boot.
How the Fear Got Started — and How It Spread
The caution around yoga and osteoporosis originates primarily from a 1984 study of 59 postmenopausal women with diagnosed spinal osteoporosis. The study found that heavy, repeated, rounded-spine loading — curl-ups performed lying on the back with knees bent — led to higher vertebral fracture rates compared to a group that did spinal extension exercises.¹
But somewhere between that 1984 study and the advice Susanne received at her doctor’s office, something went badly wrong.
The study used therapeutic curl-up exercises — not yoga. The participants all had existing osteoporosis with back pain, a high-risk subgroup. And critically, the study said nothing whatsoever about twisting.
Over the following decades, a series of case reports — reports of individual patients, not population studies — built a narrative that extrapolated far beyond what the data could support. Three patients here. A handful there. A retrospective review of 89 patients at a single clinic.²³⁴ Always from the same research group. Always patients who had already been referred for pain or fracture — a self-selected, worst-case population. None of these papers included a control group. None compared the fracture rate in yoga practitioners to the fracture rate in demographically matched non-practitioners.
And from this narrow base, a sweeping, life-altering set of prohibitions spread into mainstream medical advice, yoga studios, and the self-talk of women like Susanne.
A Prohibition Built on Nothing
Nowhere is this story clearer than with the ban on twisting poses.
When we began teaching yoga for osteoporosis around 2012, we would regularly receive messages from concerned practitioners: How can you teach twisting poses to people with osteoporosis? Everyone knows twisting yoga poses are dangerous.
Everyone knows — but where did that knowledge come from?
Dr. Loren Fishman, a physiatrist and co-author of Yoga for Osteoporosis, was one of the first to ask this question plainly. His response was straightforward: Wait a minute. There is no evidence for this. He was a strong proponent of twisting poses, arguing that they engage muscles that pull on the vertebrae in planes of movement that normal daily activity never reaches — providing a mechanical stimulus that may actually help maintain spinal integrity.
Motivated by that challenge, we conducted a comprehensive review of the medical literature — searching PubMed, Medline, and the Cochrane database for every relevant study published between 1966 and 2011. We looked specifically for evidence that twisting movements cause harm in people with osteoporosis.
We could not find a single study. Not one. Nothing. Nada. In 45 years of published research.
The results of our review were published in the International Journal of Yoga Therapy in 2013.⁵ The paper concluded that while extreme, loaded spinal flexion can increase fracture risk, there is no evidentiary basis for a blanket prohibition on twisting. The twist prohibition was not cautious medicine. It was a story that spread without ever being tested.
To understand where it came from, I interviewed a senior physical therapist who had served on the National Osteoporosis Foundation’s advisory board and taught osteoporosis safety through a university integrative medicine program. What emerged was not a scientific mandate against twisting, but a picture of a recommendation that had been stripped of its clinical context as it traveled from specialist to generalist.
Her actual position was precise: rotation performed in a loaded, seated position by a woman who already has a fixed hyperkyphotic deformity — someone whose thoracic spine is already in sustained compression before she begins to twist — is biomechanically contraindicated. That is a very different situation from rotation performed by a healthy 55-year-old with osteopenia.
Her advice to yoga teachers was equally specific: rotation should be preserved, not eliminated, because loss of spinal mobility leads to stiffness, reduced gait efficiency, and — paradoxically — higher fracture risk when even small movements push a stiff spine to its end range.
What the interview illuminated most sharply was a communication failure. Nuanced, population-specific precautions — this movement, in this type of patient, in this position — passed downstream to family physicians without clinical context, and from there to patients with even less. A conditional recommendation arrived as a blanket prohibition. The result was a game of broken telephone, played at the expense of active, healthy women with mild bone density reduction who were quietly advised to stop twisting for the rest of their lives.
What the Evidence Actually Shows
There is real, biologically plausible reason to pay attention to extreme, rounded spinal flexion in people with very low bone density. A frail, hyperkyphotic woman doing an unsupported extreme forward bend with poor alignment is in a riskier situation than a strong, well-aligned woman doing a hip-hinge forward fold with a long spine. Those are not the same pose, even if both get called “forward bend.”
The LIFTMOR trials — rigorous randomized controlled trials from the University of Queensland — put osteoporotic women through eight months of heavy resistance exercise including loaded spinal extension and impact loading. Approximately one-third of participants had prior vertebral fractures. There were zero new vertebral fractures. Balance, posture, bone density, and muscle strength all improved significantly.⁶ A 2022 systematic review led by researchers at the University of Waterloo, conducted to inform Osteoporosis Canada’s clinical practice guidelines, examined the available evidence on yoga in people at risk of fracture. It found the overall evidence to be of very low certainty and could identify no controlled data showing that yoga, as such, raises fracture risk. Where the authors did urge caution, it was narrow and specific — they advised that people with low bone mass proceed carefully with poses involving extreme spinal flexion, and recommended modifying those poses to maintain a neutral spine rather than abandoning the practice. Their guidance was to adapt and seek qualified instruction, not to impose a sweeping prohibition.⁷
What the evidence supports is narrow and specific. What it does not support is equally clear: there are no studies showing that twisting yoga poses cause fractures, no controlled incidence study showing yoga raises fracture risk above background rates, and no basis for applying high-risk precautions uniformly to healthy, active women with mild bone density reduction.
The Hidden Harm
Here is the cruel irony at the heart of Susanne’s story.
The fear of fractures led her to move less. And moving less is one of the most reliable ways to increase fracture risk.
Bone is living tissue. It responds to mechanical stress by becoming denser and stronger — and responds to the absence of that stress by losing density. Beyond bone density, reduced movement erodes everything else that prevents fractures in the real world: balance, reaction time, muscle strength, postural control, proprioception. Most fractures in older women do not happen because someone did a yoga pose. They happen because someone fell — and the ability to not fall, or to catch oneself, is entirely a function of the active physical capacities that fear-based immobility destroys.
A 2024 large-scale study found that frail, sedentary women had a hip-fracture risk nearly tripled (hazard ratio 2.70) and a vertebral-fracture risk more than doubled (hazard ratio 2.31) compared to active controls — with frailty and sedentary behavior compounding each other synergistically.⁸ The frailty cycle is real: fear → inactivity → muscle and balance loss → falls → fractures. The very outcome the restrictions were meant to prevent becomes more likely.
Susanne’s story has a sad ending. She died at 69 from complications of cancer treatment.
Did the years she spent trading the habits of a vital, active woman for those of a much frailer one play any role in that outcome? We will never know. But the question is not far-fetched.
In 1982, Stanford physician Walter Bortz II published a landmark paper in JAMA titled simply “Disuse and Aging.”⁹ His observation was radical in its simplicity: nearly every biological change medicine attributed to aging — muscle loss, bone density decline, cardiovascular deconditioning, impaired balance, depression — looks virtually identical to the changes caused by enforced physical inactivity.
Not some of them. Most of them. Two years later, he named the clinical syndrome: disuse syndrome, and concluded: “There is no drug in current or prospective use that holds as much promise for sustained health as a lifetime program of physical exercise.”¹⁰
The stakes reach far beyond bone. A 2026 meta-analysis of 53 prospective cohort studies found that frail older adults had more than twice the all-cause mortality risk of their non-frail peers.¹¹ A 2023 UK Biobank study found that physical frailty was associated with a 39% increase in cancer mortality — and even pre-frailty, often dismissed as subclinical, still carried an independent 11% increase.¹²
Frailty impairs immune surveillance, amplifies inflammation, and reduces the physiological reserve needed to tolerate treatment. A diagnosis of osteopenia that triggers progressive inactivity is not a neutral event. It sets off a chain of consequences that can reach far beyond bone.
A Different Story
Women who receive an osteoporosis or osteopenia diagnosis deserve accurate information. They deserve to know that the prohibitions many of them are handed — stop twisting, stop bending forward, stop cycling — are not evidence-based.
They deserve to know that the greatest threat to their long-term bone health is often not movement, but the fear of movement.
They deserve teachers and practitioners who understand the nuance: that some modifications are genuinely warranted for some people in some poses, and that this is entirely different from a blanket shutdown of physical life.
And they deserve to know that the research — however imperfect and incomplete — points in one consistent direction: move more, not less. Load your bones. Build your balance. Strengthen your muscles. Practice with intention, with guidance, and with the understanding that your body is not a fragile thing waiting to break.
It is a strong, adaptable, responsive system that is asking you to challenge it.
That is exactly what yoga, taught well, is designed to do.
What This Means for Yoga Teachers: Forward Bending in Practice
The 1984 Sinaki study that started this entire conversation tested something very specific: therapeutic curl-ups — performed lying on the back, knees bent, spine fully rounded — repeated five days a week, in women who already had established spinal osteoporosis with back pain. High-repetition, high-load, sustained spinal rounding in a symptomatic, high-risk population. Those were the conditions that produced harm.
That is not a yoga forward bend.
A hip-hinge forward fold with a long spine — movement originating from the hip joints, back extensors actively resisting gravity, vertebrae stacked rather than compressed — does not create those forces. Biomechanically, it is a different movement entirely.
The risk in spinal flexion is driven by how the spine moves: the degree of rounding, the load applied in that rounded position, whether the movement is sudden or repetitive, and whether the person is already hyperkyphotic — bringing a spine already under forward compression into further loading. When you teach a student to hinge from the hips with a lengthened spine, none of those risk factors are present.
The guidance from major clinical bodies has evolved precisely around this distinction. The Royal Osteoporosis Society states clearly that bending forward is generally safe — the concern is over-flexion at end range, especially under load or with uncontrolled repetition. The 2022 Osteoporosis Canada systematic review found no controlled evidence that yoga raises fracture risk, and its only caution was specific: modify poses involving extreme spinal flexion to maintain a more neutral spine, rather than eliminating forward movement altogether.
In practice, two red flags guide your teaching — no DEXA score required:
- A visibly fixed kyphotic posture: a thoracic spine already locked in forward rounding needs extra care in any loaded forward position, because compression at the front of the vertebral bodies is already elevated before the pose begins.
- Height loss of more than two inches from peak adult height: a reliable clinical signal of prior vertebral compression that warrants more conservative spinal loading.
For everyone else — the healthy, active 55-year-old with a routine osteopenia diagnosis and no postural collapse — the evidence supports continuing to practice forward bends with good alignment and appropriate cueing.
Teach the hip hinge first. Cue the spine long. Use props to support the fold without forcing end range. And recognize that a student who stops bending forward entirely loses the hip mobility, hamstring length, and neuromuscular confidence that make daily movement — and fall recovery — safe. Restriction is not neutral. It has costs of its own.
In Sum: What Good Yoga for Osteoporosis Looks Like
None of this means “do whatever you want.” It means: understand what the evidence actually shows, and teach and practice accordingly.
Good yoga for people with osteoporosis is not restricted, fearful yoga with half the poses removed. It is intelligent yoga — with attention to alignment, progressive loading, appropriate modifications, and an understanding of what each person’s body can and cannot do safely.
Keep the spine long in forward bends. The risk in forward bends is not the forward direction — it is a heavily rounded, loaded spine. A hip-hinge forward fold with a long back is fundamentally different from a collapsed, trunk-loaded forward fold. If you learn to hinge from your hips while maintaining spinal length, forward bends are not only safe — they are essential for preserving the functional mobility to tie your shoes, pick something up from the floor, or tend a garden.
Practice twists with alignment. Twists with a long spine are not only safe — they may actively support spinal health by loading the vertebrae in planes of movement that ordinary walking and sitting never reach. The concern is not the twist itself but compensated twisting in people with limited mobility who round and compress as they rotate. Teach the spine-lengthening first; the twist follows safely.
Prioritize strength, balance, and progressive challenge. The LIFTMOR research shows clearly that bones respond to mechanical challenge. A therapeutic yoga approach for bone health integrates progressive resistance, posture training, and balance work that builds the physical capacities that prevent real-world falls — not a list of forbidden movements.
Know the person in front of you. A frail woman in her 80s with severe kyphosis and multiple prior fractures and a healthy, active 55-year-old with mild osteopenia require very different approaches. A one-size-fits-all prohibition is not clinical guidance — it is an abdication of clinical judgment. The two red flags that genuinely warrant modification require no DEXA scan: a height loss of more than two inches from peak adult height, and a visibly fixed kyphotic posture.
Also, read...
The Fear That’s Hurting You More Than Osteoporosis
Bone Health: The Number Your Doctor Isn’t Telling You About:
Icicles and Gratitude
Related courses
Join Our Age Strong Community – More Courses Coming Soon!
How Not to Be Present: Understanding the Power of Mind and Consciousness
Yoga for Flexibility: Fascia, Flow, and Metabolic Efficiency
Eva Norlyk Smith, Ph.D., C-IAYT, is the founder and President of YogaUOnline. She is a lead trainer in YogaUOnline’s Yoga Wellness Educator program, an RYT-300 Yoga Alliance-approved training that focuses on giving teachers the skills they need to offer wellness courses and work with older beginners.
Eva is a trained yoga therapist at the 1,000-hour level as well as a trained bodyworker at the 500-hour level. She is the co-author of several books, including Light Years Younger with Dr. David J. Goldberg.
References
- Sinaki M, Mikkelsen BA. Postmenopausal spinal osteoporosis: flexion versus extension exercises. Archives of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation. 1984;65(10):593–596. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/6487063/
- Sinaki M, et al. Yoga spinal flexion positions and vertebral compression fracture in osteopenia or osteoporosis of spine: case series. Pain Practice. 2013;13(1):68–75. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/22448849/
- Sfeir JG, Drake MT, Sonawane VJ, Sinaki M. Vertebral compression fractures associated with yoga: a case series. European Journal of Physical and Rehabilitation Medicine. 2018;54(6):947–951. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/29687967/
- Lee M, Huntoon EA, Sinaki M. Soft tissue and bony injuries attributed to the practice of yoga: a biomechanical analysis and implications for management. Mayo Clinic Proceedings. 2019;94(3):424–431. DOI: 10.1016/j.mayocp.2018.09.024 https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/30782715/
- Boser A, Norlyk Smith E. Yoga, vertebral fractures, and osteoporosis: research and recommendations. International Journal of Yoga Therapy. 2013;23(1):17–23. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/24016820/
- Watson SL, et al. High-intensity resistance and impact training improves bone mineral density and physical function in postmenopausal women with osteopenia and osteoporosis: the LIFTMOR randomized controlled trial. Journal of Bone and Mineral Research. 2018;33(2):211–220. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/28975661/
- Kim KV, Bartley J, Ashe MC, et al.; Giangregorio LM. Effect of yoga on health-related outcomes in people at risk of fractures: a systematic review. Applied Physiology, Nutrition, and Metabolism. 2022;47(3):215–226. https://cdnsciencepub.com/doi/10.1139/apnm-2021-0736
- Zhou J, Tang R, Wang X, et al. Frailty status, sedentary behaviors, and risk of incident bone fractures. The Journals of Gerontology: Series A. 2024. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11333823/
- Bortz WM II. Disuse and aging. JAMA. 1982;248(10):1203–1208. https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jama/article-abstract/377507
- Bortz WM II. The disuse syndrome. Western Journal of Medicine. 1984;141(5):691–694. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC1011199/
- Li Y, Seo H, Cho Y, et al. Association of frailty and mortality risk in community-dwelling older adults: a systematic review and meta-analysis of 59 international prospective cohort studies (53 in meta-analysis). BMC Public Health. 2026. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC12882581/
- Liu F, Peng Y, Wang P, et al. Associations of physical frailty with incidence and mortality of overall and site-specific cancers: a prospective cohort study from UK Biobank. Preventive Medicine. 2023;177:107742. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0091743523003225
- Giangregorio LM, et al. Too Fit to Fracture: outcomes of a Delphi consensus process on physical activity and exercise recommendations for adults with osteoporosis with or without vertebral fractures. Osteoporosis International. 2015;26(3):891–910. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/25510579/
- Royal Osteoporosis Society. Strong, Steady and Straight: UK consensus statement on physical activity and exercise for osteoporosis. 2019. https://theros.org.uk/information-and-support/bone-health/exercise-for-bones/